GIS 5935 - Data Quality Assessment

Like the second assignment, this module continues to focus on data quality. More specifically, this week focused on data quality of road networks. As such, we were tasked with performing a comparative assessment to determine the completeness of a street centerline shapefile and a Topologically Integrated Geographic Encoding and Referencing (TIGER) road shapefile for Jackson County, Oregon. 

To perform this assessment we utilized a non standard method, based on that used by M. Haklay in the "Comparative Study of OpenStreetMap and Ordinance Survey datasets" in 2010. This included using a grid, which encompasses the study area, to clip the road network into smaller sections. These smaller sections give more detailed insight into areas which may be considered complete or incomplete. Once the roads were clipped to each grid cell/section the lengths were calculated and then compared. 

My analysis determined that 134 of the grid cells/sections contained parts of the street centerline file that were more complete, while 163 of the grid cells/sections contained parts of the TIGER roads file that were more complete. 

The image below shows a map displaying the geographic pattern of the differences in completeness for both road networks. In this map the cells/sections displayed in orange show a negative percent difference, indicating that the TIGER road network is more complete. While the cells/sections displayed in green show a positive percent difference, indicating that the street centerline network is more complete. 





Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

GIS 5935 - Surfaces - TINs and DEMs

Image
Having moved on from the modules regarding data quality, this week we were introduced to surfaces and surface models, more specifically Triangulated Irregular Networks (TINs) and Demographic Elevation Models (DEMs). TINs are based on vector data and are made up of a series of linked triangles that vary in shape and size, but display a 3D representation of a surface. DEMs are based on raster data, more specifically the spot heights associated with each grid part of a raster.  For this lab we were tasked with creating a TIN and DEM, as well as displaying contours based on both of them. We were then tasked with comparing the contours produced by both. Below I have included images of my results.  (a) Contour lines based on the TIN (b) Contour lines based on the DEM The contours produced as a result of the TIN appear to be more jagged, while the contours produced from the DEM have a smoother appearance. There is also a noticeable difference between the derived contours in areas that hav
Read more

GIS 5100 - Coastal Flooding

Image
During this week's module, module 4, we learned about Coastal Flooding, which can take place at various speeds, including rapidly via surge or slowly via sea level rise. This week we were tasked with performing analysis on the New Jersey shoreline and the coast of Collier County in Florida. In New Jersey we used LiDAR data to evaluate change post hurricane Sandy. This analysis included observing the raw LiDAR data, followed by the creation of Digital Elevation Models (DEMs) of pre and post hurricane Sandy for comparison. A more recent building vector file was also used to assist in the assessment of change, although using more recent data should be used with caution as it does not always accurately depict change as a result of a disaster event. This is particularly true as more time passes. The following map displays elevation change on the New Jersey Shoreline.  Map depicting elevation change post hurricane Sandy.   For Collier County, Florida, we were tasked with determining 1 me
Read more